Lending Libraries a hand
By Fred Durso Jr.
South
Philadelphia Review
March 10, 2005
Community
activists are coordinating efforts
to fight the city’s reductions in library hours and staff.
Armed with a petition containing nearly 500
signatures, Joanne Fillius is ready for battle.
The activist has been rallying community support
since the city announced that the Fumo Family Branch, 2437 S. Broad
St., would become an "express library" open afternoons only during
the week.
Fillius has used legwork, e-mail and the good old
Postal Service to spread the word about the city's budget-driven
decision to restructure a library that she said is highly utilized.
"Our library is used more than any other in the
neighborhood," said Fillius, a resident of 13th and Porter streets
and a South Philadelphia Communities Civic Association board
member. "Why they would choose ours and not one that's used less is
beyond me."
Last year, 24,164 children and adults attended
programs at the Fumo Branch, according to library officials.
In January, Mayor John Street's administration
announced plans to eliminate morning hours at 20 branches citywide,
leaving them open from just 1-5 p.m. weekdays. As a tradeoff, all 55
branches would implement Saturday hours.
The city also seeks to restructure staffing by
replacing librarians who hold master of library science degrees with
full-time nonprofessional supervisors, who will oversee part-time
assistants.
Local facilities that already have adopted the
part-time schedule are the Charles Santore (formerly Southwark)
Library, 932 S. Seventh St., and the Queen Memorial Library, 1201 S.
23rd St.
The Fumo Branch is awaiting its shift to
half-day service.
Community outcry over the cuts sparked City Council
to schedule a public meeting for March 17.
Fillius will be there, but she is not waiting to
voice her opinion. She has gathered signatures at 19 schools
participating in the Fumo Branch's programs. Members of Fillius'
townwatch group, Claws for Justice, and neighbors with whom
she communicates via e-mail also added their names to her petition.
The mother of three said her biggest concerns about
the impending changes at the Fumo Branch are the hiring of
inexperienced staff members and the elimination of some summer
programs.
Tony Greco, president of the SPCCA and a
fellow supporter of the Fumo Library, echoed Fillius' complaints.
"There's a lot of programs involving children during
the year and over the summer that might not continue without a
professional staff," he said.

FUMO BRANCH ADVOCATES
point out that the facility operates at a lower cost
than other libraries because of a unique arrangement with the city.
The branch - which had faced financial difficulties
as the Ritner Children's Branch - reopened inside the Samuel S. Fels
Community Center in 1999. The library space was later donated to the
Crime Prevention Association as part of an agreement with the city.
The Free Library incurs only the cost of operating
the branch and does not pay rent or maintenance fees at the new
building, said Greco.
"I understand the city and the Free Library are
having some economic problems," he said. "However, the Fumo Branch
has saved them a great deal of money since it opened."
Greco, who also broached his concerns to the city's
managing director, Phil Goldsmith, said he plans to send Fillius'
signed petitions to Council before next week's meeting.
Vern Anastasio, president of the Bella Vista
United Civic Association, said his group sent 200 letters and
700 e-mails informing residents of the library cuts.
Discussions with Free Library administrators on ways
to prevent the reduction in hours at the Santore Library were
unsuccessful, he added.
"Here we have a neighborhood whose youth and senior
population is growing and it's the last place they should be cutting
library services from," said Anastasio, who noted that a
representative from his association would testify at next week's
meeting.
A Bella Vista resident and Santore Library
supporter, Joan Sage has signed numerous petitions and attended a
rally against service cuts last month at the Central Library, 1901
Vine St.
Sage said she is skeptical that library cuts are the
most effective way to solve the city's budget problems.
"I'm sure there are other ways to cut costs if they
are interested," said Sage, of the 900 block of Kimball Street, who
runs a reading program at local schools.
The library lover maintains that it is a lack of
opportunity - not technology - that prevents children from
developing an appreciation for the written word.
"Why kids don't read has nothing to do with noisy
distractions," said Sage, 72, the widow of children's author Michael
Sage. "They love to read but they just need to be given the
opportunity. I think these kids would be very open to the allure of
reading if they just had the outlet."
City Council reinstated Saturday hours at library
branches by restoring funding into the fiscal 2005 budget, but was
not able to keep morning hours intact, said Council President Anna
Verna. The final reshuffling of funds is up to the mayor, she said.
"Whatever Council does or does not do, the mayor has
the ultimate say over how the monies will be appropriated and how
they will be used," Verna said.
Next week's meeting will give citizens a forum at
which to convey their frustrations to elected officials, the Council
president added.
"I think it would give people a chance to express
themselves and give Council members a chance to understand how their
constituents feel," said Verna, who has received numerous complaints
from library supporters, particularly in Southwest Philly.
Meanwhile, library proponents like Joann Mcafee, of
the 1100 block of Durfor Street, continue fighting for the
reinstatement of hours and staff at local branches.
The treasurer for the Southeast Youth Athletic
Association, Mcafee collected a handful of signatures from parents
who were tacked on to Fillius' list.
"I think that it's terrible to be cutting hours for
something so important," she said.
fdurso@southphillyreview.com